Bob Morane v1 cover detail
|

Bob Morane Resurrection v1: “Rare Earth”

Here’s what I’ve been able to figure out when it comes to the history of “Bob Morane”:

It started as a novel series written by Henri Vernes in the 1950s. Over 200 books have been written in the series now.

It led to a comic book spin-off that was serialized in various magazines including “Pilote Journal” and “Tintin Magazine.” It was fairly popular and ran for 75 albums. Maybe more. Most notably, William Vance drew 18 of the books in the middle of the run. Vance also did some incredible fully painted covers.

“Bob Morane Resurrection” was a reboot and modernization of the series in 2015. I’m guessing it wasn’t terribly successful because the “resurrection” only lasted two books. Lazarus, he is not.

I knew none of this going in. I saw the first “Resurrection” book when it was on sale. I thought it looked interesting. I opened it up to read a couple of pages and got sucked all the way through the whole thing.

There are parts that seem to be not terribly well-paced and some of it is a bit hokey, in a way, but it all fits into the pulp feeling of the property.

I enjoyed the book enough that I read the second book right away. Perhaps we’ll get to that book at some point, too. But, first, let’s do some credits and a review for this one!

The Court-Marshalled Credits

Bob Morane v1 cover
Original Title: “Bob Morane Renaissance, v1: Les terres rares”
Writers: Luc Brunschwig, Aurélien Ducoudray
Artist: Dimitri Armand
Colorist: Hugo Facio
Translator: Allison M. Charette
Letterers: Calix Ltd.
Published by: Lombard/Europe Comics
Number of Pages: 59
Original Publication: 2015

A Soldier With a Conscience Is Trouble

Bob Morane at his court martial

This script from Brunschwig and Aurélien is all plot. There’s not too a lot of characterization in it. Every scene is about the plot and moving the pieces into new places for the next twist or action set-up. Every few pages brings a twist that sends someone off into a new direction.

Bear with me while I sum up the first part of the book so I can lay out a basis from which I can discuss the book as a whole.

The book starts as we meet Bob Morane testifying in front of a military court for the “bad” thing he did. Then we jump back and see exactly what he did — saved the lives of a family while on patrol in Nigeria in direct contradiction to his non-interference orders.

If “Star Trek” taught us anything, it’s that “non-interference” is never respected and it’s always the heroes who break that rule.

The family that Morane saved includes the next president of the country, who pulls some strings to get Morane off the hook in France. Then he brings Morane back to Nigeria to be his personal advisor in dealing with France on some trade and education issues. The rest of the book centers on an educational platform that Morane is helping to set up in Nigeria with the help of France and some new technology.

Some old grudges and political enemies are not as dead and buried as previously thought, however, and the planned peaceful and well-educated country that Morane envisioned helping to create won’t be so easily created.

I just hand-waved through the entire second half of the book, which is as much on purpose for spoiler reasons as it is for lack-of-understanding issues. The events of the second half of the book won’t truly make sense until you read the second volume. This first book gives you enough and holds back plenty to push you into the second to satisfy your curiosity. It does its job well, that way.

Bob Morane's love interest

Still, there’s often a feeling that the plot is happening for the plot’s sake. I can see the Nigerian president rewarding Morane with an advisory position to help deal with his home country where he’s an outcast. I’m not sure I buy him being an education czar. There’s also a romantic interest that pops up because it’s convenient and, well, there will be more to deal with there in the second book as a plot point….

That said, the book is a good page-turner. During the middle section when you know something big is about to happy, they drag it out and ramp up the drama as far as they can take it. It does lead to a satisfying low moment for the book to help spur other things into action.

The art and storytelling by Dimitri Armand (with colors from Hugo Facio) is done well. The storytelling is super clear, with four tiers of panels. Armand doesn’t use anything too flashy to call attention to his art. There are no breakout panels or jagged panels or sudden deconstructionist tricks. This is very by-the-books in the best possible way. He tells the story with skill in ways both large and small.

His art style fits into the William Vance mode, but without being quite so heavily photo referenced. Buildings and vehicles look real, but don’t look like CAD drawings. They’re simplified just a bit to make them feel more organic.

The characters feel a little more comfortable in their skin. They’re drawn to look right without being so ridiculously stiff or detailed. There’s a bit more cartooning at work here, which I think works better. It comes a little closer at times to a John Byrne or Paul Pelletier look, if I had to make a comparison.

Facio’s colors are mostly literal. Don’t look for any fancy coloring tricks or color keyed scenes here. He keeps things realistic with a touch of a frush texture to make it feel natural. He keeps good track of the lighting in every scene, paying careful attention to atmospheric things and localized light sources like a tv screen that might brighten up a person standing nearby, or sun through a window that might cause some rim lighting. It’s effective and it stays out of the way while keeping everything easily readable.

Things don’t blend together from being colored at the same brightness or saturation. There’s definitely some separation of layers going on with the colors in this book. Credit to Racio for that.

The History of “Bob Morane”

Like I said at the top, I didn’t realize there was a whole history behind this series when I read it. Now that I know that and have read a little about it, things start to make more sense.

There are characters introduced and specifically named that didn’t seem all that relevant or important, at first. They’re legacy characters from the previous incarnations of the series. They have to be there for this to be a “Bob Morane” book.

When drones attack Bob Morane

It’s also a very modern book. There are drones involved in the second half. There are some other technologies in play that feel like the kind of futuristic technology you’d expect in a book from the last 20 years. It’s part VR and part The Matrix.

There’s also a bit of cleaning up to be done, most of which we won’t see until the second book, so I’ll hold off until then. Needless to say, a book series started in the 1950s is bound to have some attitudes and language that wouldn’t go over very well today.

All of this also helps to explain the “Ressurection” part of the title. This is a ground-up reinvention of the series for the modern audience. Maybe the original fans just wanted more of the old series, instead?

Where’s the Characterization?

Bob has a military friend

I mentioned earlier that this book is all plot. It’s true that there’s a dearth of strong characterizations here. We’re told enough of Morane’s background to make him a sympathetic character and we see in the opening of the book that he’s a moral man and can’t sit by and watch others senselessly slaughtered under his watch.

Beyond that, though, he’s a blank slate. He’s kind of dull, to be honest. He’s a no-nonsense soldier, but that also leads to a very bland character. He doesn’t have a sharp tongue or quick anger. He’s just always… there, where the plot needs him to be. Everyone in this book is a puzzle piece to be put together. It’s hard to feel anything towards most of them.

In the end, I’m interested in this book more to see where the plot is going and how everything fits together than I am in how my new friend, Bob, is making his way through this treacherous series of events. Not that it matters – he’s always in reaction mode. He doesn’t get many chances in this book to be the active and controlling interest in the story.

Recommended?

Bob Morane v1 cover

If you’re looking for a political thriller and don’t need a whole lot of characterization to enjoy it, this might be worth it for you. As an American, it’s interesting to see another country’s foreign policy be the center of a story. American political thrillers usually deal with the usual suspects, like Russia, China, or Korea. Maybe Mexico. This is France and Nigeria, which is a whole different dynamic from any of the aforementioned American entanglements.

I would recommend “Largo Winch” before this one if you’re interested in this type of thing.

Buy It Now

Izneo lists this series as “Bob Morane 2020”, which is slightly confusing as the book saw print originally in French in 2015 and in digital English translation in 2017.


What do YOU think? (First time commenters' posts may be held for moderation.)

6 Comments

  1. Bob Morane is the original YA adventure white knight hero in Belgium, in the classic MARABOUT series, for over 50 years, one new volume every 5 weeks for the first 10 years or so. Marabout was also the french publisher of Doc Savage novels. Apart from the books and the BD series, novels still being published today btw, even though Henri Vernes died of covid, he sold the character to the publisher who found some replacement, mild success there. More recently books are published as a sort of fanfic farm, with adventures split into OG BM stories set in the fifties and Modern BM stories set today. Hence the reboot, also in BD form that you are reading now.
    Originally BM is very much inspired from Flash Gordon and the Fu Manchu novels by Sax Rohmer. His arch-nemesis is called Mr Ming, the Yellow Shadow. ’nuff said. The original artist of the albums was Dino Attanasio, the man who continued Modeste et Pompon after Franquin, followed by Gerald Forton, whose name you may recognize from a few DC comics from the 1970s, as he was living in NYC at the time, lovely fellow, met him in Angoulème a few years back. When the series moved from Marabout to Lombard/Dargaud, William Vance took over, followed by his, I believe, son-in-law?, Coria, in a style fairly similar if less inspired.
    Mostly an adventure series at the beginning, à la Indiana Jones, it slowly turned to the spy genre, then fantasy, then pure SF (so exactly à la Indiana Jones then).
    If you could see behind me right now, you’d see a full bookshelf, five levels, stacked full with all the books from 1953 until roughly 2010 and the albums as well, plus a bunch of collectibles. then I ran out of space and stopped. There used to be a whole section of belgian bookstores devoted to him until the early nineties, when competition became fiercer for the male teenager’s attention and wallets.

    Let’s see what else, a very popular TV show in the 60s, boxed DVD set, sample episode right here
    youtube.com/watch?v=M2QAy_4eUIc&ab_channel=HISTOIREdeSÈTE

    and a cartoon series, also available on DVD in the 2000s. Available in full on youtube channel now
    youtube.com/channel/UC213OYJIpOYlCsHKyiGL1hA
    scroll down all the way you will see other things you might recognize as well

    Oh I almost forgot the Hit song from pop group Indochine that we can all sing by heart since we were wee lads. Enjoy.
    youtube.com/watch?v=M7X6oYg6iro&ab_channel=indochineVEVO
    This one has a bunch of fun illustrations : youtube.com/watch?v=HWEs8T9wTcA&ab_channel=ponyponygungun
    It’s in your ear forever now. HEHEHE.

    I read this BD reboot last year and was fairly unimpressed, the writer clearly does not understand the characters and this modernization just plain doesn’t work. Editorial mandate probably, to make a quick buck on name recognition, splitting into two volumes the first story was obviously a mistake and probably killed it. OG stories still continue being adapted in BD form though. Check if you can find them the Attanasio volumes and the early Forton era, real fun. The parallel you make with Largo Winch is apt, since clearly Van Hamme swiped some aspects of Largo from Bob Morane, not just XIII from Robert Ludlum 😉 they are both wordy and plot heavy as they were originally adapted from the novels. Introducing modern geopolitics to make it more topical could have been interesting but they missed the mark and TV shows do it so much better.
    In any case you just gave me today a one-hour walk down memory lane, I love Bob Morane since I was 7, so I’m smiling like an idiot right now. Thanks.

    1. Would love to see those old Bob Morane from the 60ies and 70ties translated into English. I’m from Norway and I grow up with a magazine called Tempo which published BandeDesinees weekly like Sprint magazine. Bob Morane was my favorite.

  2. There was also a Bob Morane animated series from 1998 that was a French-Canadian Co-Production.

  3. That’s certainly a lovely sentiment, but I’m afraid that Classic Bob is too generic and whitebread to make a dent into jaded modern audiences. It was created in the 50s, riffing off white knight heroes from Jules Verne, Jack London or RL Stevenson, with a dash of Hardy Boys straight adventure in there for teen male appeal. The art was cool though. Dino Attanasio was always my favourite but Forton and Vance were pretty good as well. At this point, BM books and BDs are still cruising on Nostalgia from the first two generations of readers who like myself are sadly not getting any younger. Hence the failure of this reboot which strayed too much from the core of the characters and tried to infuse a dose of “ripped from the headlines” third world politics for more grit and attempt at mirroring the original post-colonization feel, that didn’t work any more, at all.